6 Comments

Male hunters, female gatherers

Expand full comment

"There is nothing wrong with this.... obvious questions. Are women just more interested in jigsaw puzzles? Are they better at solving them?"

Imagine any activity or profession where it's mostly men participating and winning.

Can you imagine saying there is nothing wrong with it, and it's probably just because they are smarter at this activity?

Expand full comment

I don't even say what you claim -- I ask the question, which is different from saying it's probably the case.

But sure, I cannot only imagine it, that is the position I take. In this piece I even mention two things men perform better at (3d mental rotation and chess). I don't consider this is an issue.

Expand full comment

To be clear, not having a go at you and not suggesting anything wrong with what you said - on the contrary, pretty rational conclusions based on the data.

It's more about modern society and feminism. What you said is apparently perfectly fair to say for any area where women do better - teaching, non STEM graduates, arts, publishing,care, admin....

Take any field where men take interest and do better - sports, tech, STEM - and it's a patriarchal plot against women. Suggest men like to do these activities, are better at it, or it's greater variability...and you will get the Damore outcome.

Expand full comment

> It is well known, for example, that men perform better on 3d mental rotation tasks on average. One might intuitively have expected the same to be true for jigsaw puzzles.

Men also perform better on timed 2d mental rotation tasks, like "Visual Puzzles" from the WAIS-IV. It's not exactly a jigsaw puzzle, but it's really close.

Expand full comment

It’s too early to speculate.

We need to see more participation (by both sexes) and more training. I am not sure how much time people are devoting to training. The scene and prizes need to go up too.

Once those happen, my guess is that we will see what we see in professional scrabble: more female participation overall but the upper ranks will be increasingly dominated by men.

Nonetheless, here is to hoping women do better here.

Expand full comment